Recommends

OshoGirl

Joined 4 years ago

Not my favorite, but good. I've only eaten here a few times, mostly when I'm with people who are too snooty for Brooklyn's pizza. Magpie's is certainly good enough to merit a positive review, but to be honest the prices are too high for pizza, in my opinion, and the preparation is done with a heavy hand, which leads to a pizza that I find texture-ly unappealing.

Doesn't Recommend

JohnDK

Joined 5 years ago

Used to be good. This place has gone downhill over the years. The pizzas are no longer good and they have horrible customer service. If you say anything bad about the pizza to them, they start to lie and give a bunch of excuses.

This pizza place is losing customers left and right because of their fallen quality. Papa Johns pizzas are now much better than this place (and cheaper).

Doesn't Recommend

KimN70

Joined 5 years ago

Horrible Experience! Worst Pizza Ever!. Horrible pizza... expensive price... horrible employees

The pizza was cold and didn't even have the right toppings. The manager insisted they didn't make a mistake even though the menu said that The Giant had this and that toppings. Refused to give money back for their mistakes and had a horrible experience. To top it off, the pizza was cold, soggy, and tasted gross.

Doesn't Recommend

AnnS100

Joined 5 years ago

When made right, good... otherwise, HORRIBLE. At Magpies you either get a good pizza or a horrible pizza. I had some good pizzas from Magpies, like the ones from the Cortaro Farms site. But, I've also had HORRIBLE pizzas, like the ones from the Speedway site. When I say horrible, I mean the pizza didn't have the right toppings, the pizza missed a few toppings, the pizza was cold, the pizza was very soggy, the managers (like the one at the Speedway site) were rude and don't understand proper customer conduct, and bad customer service.

Magpies has a guarantee that if you don't like their pizza, they will give you a refund. That's a COMPLETE LIE. Its just a marketing ploy they will not stand by. That tells me there's a lack of integrity at Magpies.

Anyways, when I had those bad pizza, where the pizza missed some toppings, the pizza was completely cold (I arrived when they said it would be finished), the pizza was completely soggy, and the manager refused they made a mistake, I asked for the refund, but they said because the transaction already went through, they couldn't do that. I asked about their guarantee, but they said that they just "IGNOR IT."

So, at Magpies, if you're lucky, then you will get a good pizza, otherwise, it will be horrible and you lost your money.

Doesn't Recommend

peanut08

Joined 6 years ago

Cold, Soggy, Expensive Pizza that Arrived Late. Despite placing my pizza order 2 hours in advance, and asking that it PLEASE not arrive any later than 12:30pm, my order arrived 15 minutes late. Both pizzas (I ordered 2 jumbos; the white pizza and the mediterranean) were cold and barely edible, certainly not worth the $50+tip that I paid. The white pizza was flavorless and the mediterranean was soggy. I can't believe this pizza passes as 'gourmet.' Please....I've gotten better pizza at the grocery store! Maybe Magpies was having a bad day. I suppose my experience could have been a fluke but I'm certainly not going to purchase pizza from there again.

Recommends

tucsonfoodie1

Joined 6 years ago

Cant eat it there. The pizza at Magpies is good, but it doesn't live up to Eclectic Pizza... I thought the crust wasn't very flavorful, saw the options after we ordered. The topping were unusual and high quality. The sauce had great flavor. We ate the pizza at the speedway location. Two small tables made it not enjoyable to eat there. I would definately take it to go next time, if I couldn't get to Eclectic that is.

Recommends

midnightblues

Joined 6 years ago

Not bad, but way overpriced. I recently moved here from New Jersey... The pizza at Magpies isn't bad, but it doesn't live up to real NJ Italian Pizzeria pizza, and Magpies is much more expensive than anywhere else I've ever had pizza... (Over 16 dollars for a large one topping pizza which isn't really all that large.)..... I can get a steak dinner for that much, so I had to give Magpies a below average rating... To me, 16 or 17 bucks is way too much to pay for an average pizza with one topping, made by local high school kids... Maybe they raise their prices during the high tourist season, since those are January prices, but as far as I'm concerned, those prices are ridiculous.

Recommends

mogroovee

Joined 7 years ago

an explosion of flavor. This is the place to go if you're in the mood for exotic flavors and filling pizza. The greek pizza with mozzarella, feta, spinach, pine nuts, basil, garlic, and sun dried tomatoes is to die for and the spicy jc pesto with jalapenos, nuts, and cheese combos is a southwest treat. Roasted veggie salads are great too and your order is ready fairly quick. Yes the prices are higher than your ordinary pizza but you get what you pay for and this is worth it!

Recommends

olizo

Joined 7 years ago

Best pizza available!. This really is some delicious, gourmet pizza. I strongly suggest going with one of their creations or coming up with something creative yourself because a plain old one topping with regular pizza sauce won't do this place justice. The pesto is delicious and a delicious and healthy alternative is the whole wheat pizza dough. And a little hint....if you give them another pizza company's magnet, they'll take $5 off your order! Makes Magpies much more reasonably priced.

Recommends

Contributor

Joined 10 years ago

More than just pizza, this joint's pies are gourmet meals on a crust.. The Scene
Magpie's is truly gourmet pizza, with fresh ingredients in elaborate combinations. Decor, however, is bare-bones. Order at the counter even if you'll eat in rather than carry out. Delivery is available in areas close to one of Magpie's five locations.

The Food
Specialty pies like the pueblo, with spiced chile sauce, mozzarella, ground beef and roasted green chiles, made Magpies famous. The rich pesto pizza is smothered in sauce and topped with mozzarella and pine nuts. Or, build your own pizza with ingredients like artichokes, jalapenos, pineapple, roasted chicken and all the usual suspects. You also get a choice of regular, whole wheat or sourdough crust and the option to top any of those with a wonderful herb mix for extra zip. The menu also features calzones using the same build-your-own ingredients as the pizza, Buffalo wings, salads and bread sticks.